![]() |
![]() |
Grand Duel (The) AKA Il Grande duello AKA The Big Showdown AKA Storm Rider (Blu-ray)
[Blu-ray]
Blu-ray B - United Kingdom - Arrow Films Review written by and copyright: Paul Lewis (17th May 2019). |
The Film
![]() ![]() Synopsis: A stagecoach arrives at the small mining town of Gila Bend but its entry into the town itself is prevented by a group of bounty killers who have arrived in Gila Bend, placing its residents in fear of their lives, with the intention of killing and capturing Philip Vermeer (Alberto Dentice). Vermeer is a fugitive, having escaped from the law in Jefferson, and is wanted for murdering a wealthy landowner named Saxon, a founding father of Saxon City, the settlement named after him. Aboard the stagecoach is Clayton (Lee Van Cleef), the disgraced former sheriff of Saxon City. Clayton coolly disobeys the bounty killers who have ‘locked down’ Gila Bend, using a variety of techniques to reveal their locations to Vermeer so that Vermeer knows where they are hiding. When a gunfight breaks out between the bounty hunters and Vermeer, Clayton assists Vermeer in escaping from Gila Bend, offering him a ride in the stagecoach – much to the chagrin of his bourgeois fellow passengers. The stagecoach stops for the night at the Silver Bell staging post. During the evening, Vermeer informs his fellow travellers that he is wanted for the murder of old man Saxon (Horst Frank), nicknamed ‘the Patriarch’, because Vermeer had a strong motive for killing Saxon: Saxon had Vermeer’s father murdered, so as to get his hands on the silver-rich land that Vermeer’s father owned. The group are once again surrounded by bounty killer, but Clayton and Saxon manage to flee. The pair reach Saxon City, which is now presided over by the Patriarch’s three spoilt, entitled sons: Eli (Marc Mazza), who plays at being the town’s sheriff; the cruel and sadistic Adam (Klaus Grunberg), who delights in causing suffering and committing murder; and the oldest of the siblings, David (Horst Frank, in a dual role), who has been using the funds from his family’s ‘acquisition’ of the Vermeer silver mine to further his political ambitions. ![]() Critique: Released under a plethora of titles (including The Big Showdown, Hell’s Fighters and Storm Rider) in various territories, The Grand Duel was one of a series of westerns all’italiana/Spaghetti Westerns that featured Lee Van Cleef as an austere ‘mentor’ to a younger gunslinger. To cite but two examples, this paradigm underpins Tonino Valerii’s I giorni dell’ira (Day of Anger, 1967), in which Van Cleef mentors Giuliano Gemma’s aspiring gunfighter; and Giulio Petroni’s Da uomo a uomo (Death Rides a Horse, also 1967), which focuses on Van Cleef’s character assisting John Phillip Law in exacting revenge upon the men who killed his parents. Bert Fridlund has referred to these films as ‘tutorship’ Westerns, noting that in The Grand Duel, as in Death Rides a Horse and Day of Anger, Van Cleef’s character ‘is party to a misdeed against’ his younger companion (Fridlund, 2006: 168). As Fridlund observes, The Grand Duel somewhat inverts the mentor/mentee relationship seen in Death Rides a Horse and Day of Anger: in those films, the younger mentee (John Philip Law/Giuliano Gemma) pursues the somewhat unwilling mentor (Van Cleef) and tries to deepen their relationship; in this picture, it is the other way around, with Clayton pursuing Vermeer. And where, in Death Rides a Horse and Day of Anger, Van Cleef’s character offers fairly structured ‘lessons’ to the mentee (in the case of Day of Anger, Van Cleef offers Gemma a series of numbered protocols for a career as a gunfighter), in The Grand Duel ‘[t]he actual “tutoring” [of the younger character by Van Cleef] is also considerably diluted’ (ibid.). ![]() ![]() ![]() With the whodunit plot driving it, the narrative of The Grand Duel builds towards its climactic ‘grand duel’ in which Clayton faces off against the three Saxon brothers in a cattleyard. Each brother stands in a separate cattle pen; and as Clayton advances, each Saxon brother, in turn, backs through a gate into the next pen. As Alex Cox has noted in his book 10,000 Ways to Die: A Director’s Take on the Spaghetti Western, this sequence displays a visual flourish which nevertheless, on a narrative level at least, doesn’t make a great deal of sense. But then, the same could be said of many westerns all’italiana, from Leone’s Per un pugnio di dollari/A Fistful of Dollars (1964) onwards. As Cox says in his discussion of the aforementioned climax from The Grand Duel, ‘[a]s a filmmaker, you enjoy it because you know there’s a crew member hiding out of shot, who grabs the gate and stops it flying back and hitting Lee Van Cleef. But why does David Saxon […], having thrown open his gate, walk backwards, in unison with brother Eli […]? It looks good, and it’s done in time to the music. But doesn’t walking backwards while maintaining eye contact with Lee Van Cleef put you at a disadvantage? All is sacrificed for the conceit of the shot, and to the Spaghetti Western convention that villains, about to be shot, will stand in a straight line’ (Cox, 2010). ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Video
![]() The film exists in a variety of different cuts. The film’s earliest DVD releases, from SPO in Japan and Wild East in the US (where it was paired with Beyond the Law), caused some consternation amongst fans in online forums when it was discovered that these presentations omitted some snippets of material that could be found in the German VHS release of the picture. These releases contained a slightly shorter cut of the film that was apparently prepared for the Italian domestic market. (That said, the elusive German VHS cut was itself missing over a minute of footage that was otherwise to be found in the shorter Italian cut of the picture.) Whilst Arrow's Blu-ray release is longer than the SPO/Wild East DVD releases, it is also shorter than the aforementioned German cut, the unique scenes from which are presented separately and discussed in the featurette entitled 'Two Different Duels' that is contained within the contextual material on the disc. The presentation is based on a new 2k restoration which uses the negative as its source. The Grand Duel was shot in Techniscope, the 2-perf widescreen format in which many westerns all’italiana were photographed. This presentation retains the film’s intended aspect ratio of 2.35:1. As with other Techniscope pictures, the film was made using spherical lenses. Techniscope and similar 2-perf widescreen processes were cost-saving in the sense that they enabled the production of a widescreen image without the use of expensive anamorphic lenses, and by reducing the size of each frame by half (from 4-perforations to 2-perforations) halved the negative costs involved in making a film. (However, this was reputedly offset to some extent by more expensive lab costs, which for Techniscope productions steadily increased throughout the 1970s; this is sometimes cited as one of the reasons why Techniscope became less popular during the late 1970s and early 1980s.) ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Some full-sized screengrabs are included at the bottom of this review. Please click to enlarge them.
Audio
![]() There are some interesting differences between the Italian dialogue and that of the English language version. Most of this amounts to exchanges that are very slightly different in terms of their connotations but which don’t have a great deal of bearing on the narrative. In the English version, the dispute between Vermeer and the Saxons focuses on Vermeer’s father’s discovery of silver; in the Italian version, it’s a vein of gold that is the source of the territorial dispute. Near the start of the film, two bounty hunters discuss the stagecoach which has arrived at Gila Bend; in the English version, one of the bounty hunters assert, ‘Shit, I thought we was meant to be stopping people’. In the Italian version, the character instead asks the rhetorical question, ‘So we’re just going to let everyone in?’ Elsewhere, the Italian track is ‘busy’ in moments which, in the English track, are dominated by silence: when Vermeer and Clayton are holed up in Gila Bend, for example, the Italian version features the cries and yells of the bounty killers outside, but on the English track the scene is quiet except for ambient foley effects.
Extras
![]() - An audio commentary by Stephen Prince. Prince offers a typically well-researched and detailed track that explores The Grand Duel’s relationship with other examples of the Spaghetti Western, particularly through the manner in which the film exploits/capitalises on Van Cleef’s persona in these pictures. Prince explores the production of the film and considers too the input of the film’s key crew. - ‘An Unconventional Western’ (31:40). Director Giancarlo Santi is interviewed and talks about how he was approached to direct the film after Lee Van Cleef had already been signed as the star of it. The film’s producers knew Santi from his days as an assistant to directors like Marco Ferreri and Sergio Leone. Santi reflects on how they found financing for the picture and describes The Grand Duel as a ‘lucky break’ which led him to feeling ‘compelled to do a good job and repay their trust’. He talks about the ‘spat’ he had with Sergio Leone, when after Once Upon a Time in the West Leone described Santi as his ‘heir’ and told him he would direct the next picture. With Duck, You Sucker, Santi was advertised as the director of the picture but Rod Steiger wanted Leone to direct the film, so Santi was replaced. Santi goes on to discuss his relationship with Leone following The Grand Duel and offers an anecdote as to how he was asked to direct My Name is Nobody. Santi also discusses the lasting legacy of The Grand Duel and describes Tarantino’s use of Luis Bacalov’s music from The Grand Duel as ‘wrongful cultural appropriation [… and] downright theft’. The interview is in Italian with optional English subtitles. ![]() - ‘The Last of the Great Westerns’ (25:37). Ernesto Gastaldi talks about his role as the film’s scriptwriter. Gastaldi reflects on Santi’s emulation of Leone’s style and says the film is simply ‘a western. We weren’t looking for a masterpiece’ though did very well at the box office. Gastaldi offers a reflection of an event at which Leone and Santi met, after the success of The Grand Duel, and Leone observed that Santi had ‘grown a beard like mine’, adding that ‘Only geniuses and assholes can have a beard like that’. Santi was embarrassed and didn’t know how to react, but Gastaldi quipped back, ‘Sergio, don’t tell me you think you’re a genius’. Gastaldi adds that he has always ‘abhorred the idea of men in positions of power abusing or humiliating those working for them’. This interview is in Italian with optional English subtitles. - ‘Cowboy by Chance’ (35:32). Alberto Dentice reflects on how he came to be an actor in films. He reflects on some of the pictures he shot, linking his work with the countercultural movement of the late 1960s, and he talks about how he came to be associated with Michelangelo Antonioni, meeting Santi during the production of The Passenger. He also describes working with Van Cleef, suggesting that Van Cleef was ‘a man of few words’ whose presence was nevertheless ‘mesmerising’. Dentice and Van Cleef would play guitar together during their time off-set. The interview is in Italian with optional English subtitles. - ‘Out of the Box’ (29:02). Producer Ettore Rosboch discusses his role in the making of The Grand Duel, a film that was made because his co-producer Croscicki came into possession of a contract signed by Lee Van Cleef which meant that Van Cleef was obliged to star in another film. Rosboch suggests that ‘from a production standpoint, the western is a complex genre’ which requires the investment of a lot of time and money into staging some of its action scenes and getting costumes and sets right. This interview is also in Italian with optional English subtitles. - ‘The Day of the Big Showdown’ (21:07). In this interview, assistant director Harald Buggenig discusses his role in the making of The Grand Duel and reflects at length about the casting of the picture, including some of the smaller roles. Buggenig speaks in Italian; optional English subtitles are provided. - ‘Saxon City Showdown’ (15:32). Lecturer Austin Fisher, the author of Radical Frontiers in the Spaghetti Western: Politics, Violence and Popular Italian Cinema (2011), reflects on the position of The Grand Duel within the history of the western all’italiana and connects the picture to Van Cleef’s onscreen persona, which he suggests anchors many of these films (both through Van Cleef’s performance/s and roles played by other actors which were clearly modelled on the Colonel Mortimer character in For a Few Dollars More). Fisher offers a cogent and articulate analysis of The Grand Duel. ![]() - ‘Two Different Duels’ (15:38). This featurette focuses on the differences between the cut of the film presented on Arrow’s Blu-ray and the longer cut of the film released in Germany. This is achieved by a side-by-side onscreen comparison of the scenes that are differently edited in the German cut, accompanied by onscreen text explaining the differences. Scenes unique to the German cut are presented within this featurette in standard definition as they were not included in the film elements Arrow were given access to when preparing the HD master for this release. Arrow have included similar featurettes on their recent Jose Ramon Larraz releases and this is equally well-assembled and most welcome. - ‘Game Over’ (9:12). This is an odd one: a strange, enigmatic short science fiction film from 1984 which stars Marc Mazza. It’s an effective, well-shot picture with a haunting synth score. - ‘Marc Mazza: Who Was the Rider on the Rain?’ (12:32). Mike Malloy narrates a video essay about the actor Marc Mazza, who plays Eli Saxon. Malloy reflects on Mazza’s career as a bit part actor who was near-ubiquitous in 1970s Eurocrime pictures and who would crop up in the most unusual places. - Trailers: International Trailer (2:56); Italian Trailer (2:56). - Galleries: Stills, Posters and Press (3:00); Lobby Cards (5:40); Super 8mm, Home Video and Soundtrack Sleeves (2:40).
Overall
![]() Arrow’s Blu-ray release of The Grand Duel contains an outstanding presentation of the main feature and is supported by an equally impressive array of contextual material. The interviews with various participants in the production of the picture are complemented by the interview with Austin Fisher, who helps to give the film a sense of context. The short science fiction film ‘Game Over’ is an odd inclusion but a fascinating one nonetheless. Although The Grand Duel may not be one of the best westerns all’italiana, it’s a strong example from late in the cycle, and for fans of Spaghetti Westerns Arrow’s Blu-ray release of this film will most likely be one of the best releases of the year. References: Cox, Alex, 2010: 10,000 Ways to Die: A Director’s Take on the Spaghetti Western. Manchester: Kamera Curti, Roberto, 2016: Tonino Valerii: The Films. London: McFarland & Company Fridlund, Bert, 2006: The Spaghetti Western: A Thematic Analysis. London: McFarland & Company Please click to enlarge: ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
|||||
![]() |